Categories: South Africa

Fishing company interdicts DAFF on inshore trawl permits

An interdict reportedly granted by the Western Cape High Court has temporarily prevented the Department of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries…

The interdict was obtained by the Viking Inshore Fishing (VIF) company and prevents 27 fishing companies, including VIF, from starting to catch their 2017 quotas.

A statement from VIF said that the company was compelled to seek the interdict after DAFF reportedly cut VIF’s inshore hake and sole quota by approximately 60% apparently to make space for new entrants into the SA inshore trawl fishery.

This was despite VIF having reportedly achieved the second-highest score in DAFF’s process to rank aspirant rights holders in this fishery.

READ Aquaculture 101: the advantages of greenhouse tunnels

“A 60% cut in our quota will devastate our business and see us lay-up three or four vessels, leaving their skippers and fishing crews without work, and in due course close down our hake and sole handling, packing and processing factory in Mossel Bay. We decided we couldn’t do that to our people,” said VIF spokesperson, Tim Reddell.

VIF said that, in his court order, Judge Lee Bozalek said that VIF had established a prima facie case that the rights allocations by DAFF for the inshore hake and sole fishery were “unlawful, irrational, and procedurally unfair”, and that VIF had a reasonable prospect of success in appealing its quota.

In terms of the interdict granted by Bozalek, the inshore trawl fishery for hake and sole would be suspended outright until the matter was heard fully by the Western Cape High Court in February 2017.

“We are of the view that cutting quotas of existing rights holders – particularly those that have built up fishing fleets, processing infrastructure, and marketing networks over several decades – in favour of irrationally promoting new entrants, will destroy value as opposed to creating opportunities in the fishing industry,” said Reddell.

DAFF minister, Senzeni Zokwana, said in a statement that he and the deputy director-general of DAFF’s Fisheries Management Branch, Siphokazi Ndudane, were “greatly perturbed by the apparent unlawfulness of the order granted”.

“The urgent interim interdict application ought to have been refused by the Court. The Court Order creates a legal lacuna in that appeals in this fishery are due by 17 March 2017 but a review application concerning the very decisions to be subjected to an appeal will be heard on 06 February 2016,” Zokwana said.

DAFF’s minister said that he and his colleagues would be seeking legal opinion to determine the most appropriate way forward on the matter.

VIF said that it elected to approach the court regarding its concerns with the rights allocation process, instead of appealing the process in DAFF’s own internal systems, because the latter appeals process would likely take at least six months to conclude.

Recent Posts

Indigenous livestock perfect for small-scale farmers

Ross Rayner and his father, Roger, farm 40 Nguni cows and 35 Bosvelder-type ewes on 250ha in the Mankazana Valley…

21 hours ago

Researchers urged to get out into the field

More than 250 delegates are attending the annual Combined Congress of soil, crop production, weed and horticultural sciences, underway at…

23 hours ago

Praise for teamwork in containing foot-and-mouth outbreak

The rapid response by both government and the private sector to the recent foot-and-mouth disease (FMD) outbreak in the Vhembe…

23 hours ago

Homeland consolidation: a forerunner of land reform?

Zimbini Coka, a junior lecturer at the University of the Free State’s Department of Agricultural Economics, visited areas that became…

2 days ago

‘Parts of the Free state must be declared a disaster area’

The Free State consists of many economic sectors, but agriculture is the most important in terms of food security for…

2 days ago

White horses and black bulls

Camargue horses are used to manage the feral black cattle herds in the salty marshes of the Rhône River Delta…

3 days ago

This website uses cookies.