Categories: Aquaculture

Generalist and specialist fish species

Not all fish species are suitable for aquaculture simply because they grow large in their natural habitat.

In Lake Tanganyika in East Africa, there is a large, endemic species of tilapia called Oreochromis tanganicae. Specimens of between 2kg and 3kg are caught regularly as part of the commercial fishery catch. Like all tilapia, it makes good eating – but is it suitable for aquaculture?

The answer requires examination of its biology to determine whether it is a generalist or a specialist species. Generalists thrive in a variety of environments, whereas specialists can thrive only in a narrow range of conditions.

READ:Balancing tilapia production with conservation

Generalists
The most successful tilapia for aquaculture is O. niloticus (Nile tilapia), a riverine species that occurs over a wide variety of habitats, from the Nile River in Egypt to waterways in West Africa and southwards to the marshy fringes of Lake Tanganyika.

It is exposed to a wide range of environments and water conditions. Often, these conditions change rapidly, when rivers flood or swamps dry up. At such times, the water quality may experience wide variations in pH, oxygen content, temperature and turbidity. O. niloticus has evolved with these changes over millennia, and its genetic makeup and physiology can accommodate them.

O. mossambicusis (Mozambique tilapia)is even more tolerant of salinity variance, from freshwater to over 40ppt (parts per thousand). This salinity tolerance level is higher than that of some marine species. It can survive temperature extremes (10°C to 40°C) and low oxygen levels (2mg/l to 3mg/l) that would kill many other freshwater fish.

If its natural habitats are investigated, this tolerance of extremes is not surprising; O. mossambicusis lives in almost all freshwater bodies, permanent or seasonal, from tropical Tanzania southwards to the Eastern Cape.

It is thus obvious why these two species form the backbone of most tilapia culture. They comfortably tolerate the changeable, crowded and environmentally harsh conditions in fish farms, and adapt easily to artificial feeds, high stocking densities, handling and less-than-optimal water quality – yet still grow vigorously.

Specialists
Based on its biology of being endemic to only one large, clear water, ancient lake, it seems unlikely that O. tanganyikae would fare as well. When an animal has evolved under such stable conditions, and has shown no signs of spreading elsewhere, it is generally not well-equipped to prosper under culture conditions.

In 1962, Lake Kariba was stocked with fingerlings of O. macrochir from the Chilanga fish farm in Zambia. The experiment was a failure; the stock originated from the Kafue River population that evolved under variable riverine conditions, and were not the best choice for a 5 000km2 clear water lake.

Later, it was realised that a lacustrine subspecies occurs naturally in Lake Mweru (O. macrochir mweruensis); although the same species, it has evolved under stable lake conditions. It is likely that this lake form would have been suitable for stocking Lake Kariba, whereas the riverine form failed.

Nicholas James is an ichthyologist and hatchery owner.

This article was originally published on 03 June 2016 in Farmer’s Weekly.

Share
Published by
Tags: environment fish farming tilapia

Recent Posts

  • South Africa

Additional vehicles to combat crime in the Free State welcomed

Free State Agriculture (FSA) has welcomed the deployment of 48 additional vehicles made available by the South African Police Service…

13 mins ago
  • Farming for Tomorrow
  • Featured Home Image

Designing an irrigation system according to soil type

Dr Willem de Clercq, a researcher at the Water Institute at Stellenbosch University, says that all farmers, and especially those…

1 hour ago
  • Caxton
  • Use only text
  • World

Major losses for Canadian agri sector due to labour shortages

It is estimated that the Canadian agriculture sector suffered C$2,9 billion (about R30 billion) in lost sales in 2018, due…

3 hours ago
  • Aquaculture

How to distinguish similar-looking juvenile cichlids

Approximately 15 cichlid species occur in South Africa. To the untrained eye, several appear confusingly alike, especially as juveniles. So…

1 day ago
  • Featured Home Image
  • Managing for Profit

Yield and quality determine profits, nothing else!

Costs under your control such as yield and product quality are what determine farming success. Don’t waste time on costs…

2 days ago
  • Caxton
  • South Africa
  • Use only text

Mixed reaction expected from agri sector to repo rate reduction

The decision by the South African Reserve Bank Monetary Policy Committee to lower the repo rate to 6,5%, down from…

3 days ago