Categories: Aquaculture

Small aquaculture systems: the simpler, the better!

Because of their scale, these systems have very limited yields. Choosing a complex, small system will not increase yield; it will only increase cost!

Many people get involved in aquaculture experimentally; they are keen to try it out and hope to develop it further if it proves attractive. There is nothing wrong with this. But problems can arise if it is done the wrong way.

READ Understanding semi-hydroponic systems

A small recirculating aquaculture system (RAS) is often the preferred option for people reluctant to commit to something with a larger footprint.

The trouble is that a small, but complex system, like this may not be viable because there is no economy of scale. A small, earthen pond of 0,25ha, which is both simple and cheap to build, is likely to provide a better annual return than a small RAS system.

A proven success

In rural areas of Africa, Asia and South America, most people considering aquaculture would begin with a small earthen pond.

Today, this is likely to be far removed from the subsistence-type ‘pond’ widely promoted in the 1960s, which was usually stocked with poor- quality fish of unknown ancestry, fed on kitchen scraps.

Unsurprisingly, 99% of these failed to produce significant yields.

The typical ‘small pond’ of today is about 0,25ha in area, fully drainable, and stocked with all-male Nile tilapia of an improved genetic strain sourced from professional breeders.

The water is fertilised to increase primary productivity (zooplankton and phytoplankton, all natural food for the fish), and the fish are pellet-fed with good-quality fish feed.

The expected annual yield from such a venture may well be between 3t and 4t of similarly-sized tilapia.

Admittedly, these systems are weather-dependent, so are suited to warmer areas. But even in South Africa’s hot summers and cool winters, they can still utilise the eight warmer months to produce significant yields.

Now compare these simple, yet effective, systems with the RAS so often seen in the peri-urban environment of this country. Townsfolk, it seems, love plumbing! Any system that looks like a scaled-down Sasol oil-from-coal plant must be good, or so it is widely believed.

Thus, backyard and starter systems often have elaborate rows of plastic tanks, all coupled to machines that clean and oxygenate the crystal clear water.

These include drum separators, drum filters, degassers, oxygen cones, oxygen generators, swirl filters… the list goes on. To justify the cost of not only setting up, but operating, this technology, the stocking rate has to be very high, up to 30kg/m3 water or even more.

Now, how much would a small (say, 30m x 10m) tunnel-based system like this produce if run competently? The answer: exactly the same as the humble pond system: between 3t and 4t of tilapia annually!

Both are seasonal systems, with seasonal production.

It is not financially viable to heat either to the optimal temperatures of between 28°C and 30°C to sustain growth and production all year round.

The running costs of the recirculation system, however, will be high, whereas that of the pond will be low. The construction costs of the pond system will be about 40% that of the other.

Make your choice.

Nicholas James is an ichthyologist and hatchery owner.

Share
Published by
Nicholas James

Recent Posts

  • Featured Home Image
  • Managing for Profit

Yield and quality determine profits, nothing else!

Costs under your control such as yield and product quality are what determine farming success. Don’t waste time on costs…

4 hours ago
  • Caxton
  • South Africa
  • Use only text

Mixed reaction expected from agri sector to repo rate reduction

The decision by the South African Reserve Bank Monetary Policy Committee to lower the repo rate to 6,5%, down from…

23 hours ago
  • Recipes

Carrot cake loaf with dates

This carrot cake loaf, with its delicious, zesty cream-cheese icing and chopped walnuts, is soft and full of flavours.

24 hours ago
  • Caxton
  • South Africa
  • Use only text

Jobs and safety to take centre stage in the Western Cape

Western Cape Premier, Alan Winde, delivered his maiden State of the Province address on Thursday, focusing on job creation and…

1 day ago
  • Caxton
  • Use only text
  • World

Australian table grape exports reach half-a-billion mark

As the Australian grape export season nears an end, it is estimated that volumes amounting to half a billion Australian…

1 day ago
  • Featured Home Image
  • How to Crop

Fertilisation: basic principles that every farmer should know

Achieving optimal yields is greatly dependent on providing crops with the right nutrition at the right time. Understanding the role…

1 day ago