Premier took full control of the facility in March 2026, after acquiring the previous owner, Rhodes Food Group, in a R5,7 billion merger deal.
Farmers want Premier to honour the original long-term contracts they had with Rhodes Food Group before the merger. However, Premier maintains that closing the Tulbagh processing plant was necessary due to tough global market conditions and a worsening operating environment since the takeover.
A proposal is currently on the table for five canning fruit producers pursuing legal action against Premier, said Jacques Jordaan, CEO of the Canning Fruit Producers’ Association. Under the proposal, Premier would honour the terms of their original long-term rolling contracts for this season. The parties would then refer the dispute for arbitration to determine the way forward. The original contracts specified a two-year notice period for termination.
“If finalised, this agreement might eliminate the need for these producers to return to court and allow them to continue supplying their fruit as stipulated in their original contracts for at least this season,” Jordaan told Farmer’s Weekly.
Should the parties fail to agree on this proposal, the interdict hearing will proceed.
Premier agreed to receive the fruit of the rest of the producers for this season but require them to give up all their contractual rights and claims. They are also denied the option of arbitration.
“Although the apricot harvest started this week, producers still have not received any alternative contracts from Premier and face the difficult reality of harvesting their crops in the coming weeks without valid agreements in place,” Jordaan said.
Such a scenario leaves growers deeply vulnerable regarding exact delivery volumes, pricing, and the full extent of their legal liabilities.
In its interim results for the six months ended September, published earlier this month, Premier insisted the Tulbagh plant closure was unrelated to the merger.
The Competition Commission is considering revoking the merger approval or imposing amended conditions, but Premier dismissed the likelihood of the Competition Appeal Court undoing the transaction. According to Premier there was no contemplation of closure prior to approval.
Maintaining that it is engaging constructively with stakeholders, Premier said in its results presentation that it has supported farmers through settlement agreements for the removal of some orchards, and committed to paying for fruit harvested this season while making the Tulbagh factory available for new job-creating ventures.
The Canning Fruit Producers’ Association responded with a statement condemning Premier’s conduct as “commercially oppressive”. The association said growers were initially assured Premier’s acquisition of Rhodes Food Group Holdings would change nothing, only to be told the company would take no canning fruit for the season, followed by last-minute settlement deadlines as harvest approached.
“Premier presents these arrangements as support for farmers, but does not explain the rights they must surrender. That gives the public an incomplete picture,” the Canning Fruit Producers’ Association stated.
The association wants Premier to make workable arrangements for this harvest without demanding that farmers abandon their future rights.

